Responses 1-2, Week 1
I honestly cannot accurately describe how much I absolutely love what you've done with Addonizio's piece. Alone, her piece is strong and bold, and it would be so easy to fall under the weight of expectation as it relates to her. You, though, have managed to avoid that. Your piece isn't consumed by the waves of Addonizio's legacy; you make it your own. Your postmodern take is self-evident. Line 5 just blew me away. You took her concrete image and quite literally liquified it. "1 fl oz" and "bottled" has such pro-feminist potential. An item made to target women that is, much like oppressed feminity, kept small and confined. I also enjoyed the allusions to Exon and McDonalds, which further draws the piece into a postmodern consciousness. The "skin glittering" and "old Exon" with "day-old pies" seems to suggest a rupture of one's identity due to the rampant consumerist ideology under which society buries itself. Then, when you consider the twilight woods brand and the desire to have it and the fact that it causes the glittering adds to the power of your postmodern critique of inauthentic identity.
I do keep in mind, however, that this may not have been your intention at all. But isn't it kinda funny how many interpretations can be drawn by many different individuals? Quite fascinating.
To Dee's "Home":
I just have to say that I never thought the word "yum" could ever be employed as brilliantly as it is in this piece. That one three-lettered word separates the former half--the recipe--and the latter half. I keep reading it back to myself aloud, testing to see how it would sound without the word "yum." It really makes all the difference. It is simple, quick, and easy; but you've employed it in such a way that it--and it alone--allows the piece to flow neatly without sounding choppy or disproportionate.
My favorite is line 11: "...a child later named jazz." Two things strike me immediately: one, jazz isn't capitalized; and two, the delay between "child" and "named." By not capitalizing "jazz," it begs a series of questions related to identity and personification. If "jazz" was a person, then it would mean that the "child" was named some time after birth. It makes me wonder, "Exactly what is this thing called humanity, and what holds it together--culture? music? practices? food?"
This is just simply beyond brilliant, and I'm so glad that I finally read through it. Keep editing and polishing, and this will surely become a beloved piece by many. Bloody brilliant.